Showing posts with label gerrymander. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gerrymander. Show all posts

Sunday, December 19, 2010

Redistricting Nuts-and-Bolts, Part 1


This redistricting cycle will see Michigan losing a seat from its Congressional delegation. De rigeur in these situations is to combine two districts controlled by the opposing party, forcing the two incumbents into a primary that only one of them can win. Ideally, you hope that one of these districts is represented by a long-time Congressional veteran, the other represented by a relative newcomer and rising star in the other party. These primary races tend not to be kind to the newbies, so combining districts typically serves to short-circuit otherwise promising political careers. The gerrymandering party is left with one Congressperson they’ve dealt with for decades and a former Congressperson with lots of potential and nowhere to go but down.

Under the usual run of things, those districts in Michigan would be the 13th and 14th, which will be represented in the upcoming 112th Congress by freshman Congressman Hansen Clarke and born-in-a-committee-hearing Capitol Hill veteran John Conyers, respectively. However, because these districts are Michigan’s only majority-minority districts, this is not the usual run of things. A full explanation of majority-minority districts can be found here, but the relevant information about them is that they’re one of the tools created by the Voting Rights Act to prevent minorities from being disenfranchised through redistricting.

Sunday, December 12, 2010

The Sky Isn't Actually Falling


With respect to the Chicken Littles of Michigan Democratic politics, I’m not ready to throw my hat in with the “complete Republican control over the redistricting process will mean the end of the Michigan Democratic Party, and possibly the Apocalypse” crowd quite yet. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying it’s a good thing: it’s much worse than the alternatives of split or Democratic control. Nonetheless, even if optimism isn’t quite called for, we should put off seppuku for at least another election cycle.
The reasons I’m staying sanguine about Democratic chances for the next decade fall into roughly two categories: 1. Republicans controlled the redistricting process in 2001, so the current districts are already Republican-gerrymandered: The only difference between the new districts they’ll draw and the current ones will be that the gerrymander will be more up-to-date. 2. There are simply too many Democrats in this state (assuming they actually get to the polls) for any drawing of the lines to solidify Republican majorities for long.

The argument I’m making – that the Republican screw-job we’re about to experience come redistricting time won’t be that much worse than the status quo – carries with it a very depressing corollary: that the Republican screw-job we’ve been dealing with for the past ten years has been remarkably effective.